Frosty vs Santa

There's a huge controversy because the McBurney YMCA in New York City replaced Santa with Frosty the Snowman as the "star" of its annual Christmas luncheon. What a blizzard of comments resulted! I've been laughing all evening at what I found just by googling "Frosty replaces Santa". The best I can do is copy the article from the New York Post.

West Village YMCA axes Santa Claus for Frosty
By SUSANNAH CAHALAN and CYNTHIA R. FAGEN
Last Updated: 11:50 AM, December 12, 2010
Posted: 12:21 AM, December 12, 2010

He's a lost Claus.
A politically correct West Village YMCA has fired Ol' St. Nick in favor of Frosty.
Kids who once thrilled at sitting on Santa's lap at the 14th Street McBurney YMCA's wildly popular annual holiday luncheon will now suffer the icy embrace of a talking snowman and his sidekick, an anonymous penguin, at today's event. Forget about bringing a list or checking it twice -- Frosty doesn't take gift requests, and doesn't care if you're naughty or nice. YMCA officials, who say they are in the midst of "rebranding" the Young Men's Christian Association to "The Y," defended their decision.

THAT'S COLD! A West Village YMCA has given Santa Claus the boot in favor of Frosty the Snowman for its holiday luncheon. "It wasn't replacing; it was transitioning," said John Rappaport, executive director of the McBurney YMCA. "We realized that change is sometimes good, and that Frosty is a great winter character who would appeal to a broader number of kids."

The decision to ditch Father Christmas came down from McBurney branch administration, not the Y's Chicago headquarters. A chilly reception greeted the news that the YMCA -- an organization founded to spread Christian values in 1844 -- was replacing the Christmas icon with a secular cartoon character.

"Christmas is not about Jack Frost; it's not about snowmen," fumed Bill Donohue of the Catholic League. "We're not talking about some secular organization that has no religious roots. If they can't celebrate Christmas, then they should check out. What a bunch of cowards." "Santa belongs to all the people," added Ed Bobrow, who has played Santa at Central Park's Belvedere Castle for years. "He represents openness and an invitation for anyone and everyone to celebrate good will toward man." Bobrow, who is Jewish, says it's the kids who will miss out. "Try to see it through the eyes of the children," he said. "It's sad that people are so offended by a man in a red suit," said Taylor Patterson, an 18-year-old member of the McBurney Y. "It's not a Christian thing. It is the spirit of the holiday that counts. I think the Y is well intended, but misguided."

Director Rappaport offered an olive branch to critics, insisting that everyone is welcome today -- even "Santa . . . if he's in town."